A bee-friendly garden that doesn't feed wasps
It's a fair worry. You plant a border of lavender and borage for the bees, and by February the garden has a second set of visitors, thinner and more purposeful, who aren't interested in the flowers at all. A bee-friendly garden and a wasp-friendly garden overlap in a few places, and it helps to know which.
The good news is that bees and wasps want different things. A garden designed around flowers feeds bees; the wasps are drawn mainly by protein and sugar from other sources, and most of that is under your control.
What bees want
The Auckland Beekeepers Club suggests a few simple rules for planting. Bees favour blue, purple, white and yellow flowers, and simple, single-layered petals are easier to land on and get nectar from than doubled ones. Winter-flowering plants fill the gap when other food is scarce (Auckland Beekeepers Club).
The club's lists of dependable plants are practical for a suburban garden:
- Daisy family: asters, sunflowers, zinnias, cosmos and even dandelions.
- Mint family: basil, catmint, lavender, lemon balm, mint, rosemary, sage, salvias and thyme.
- Borage family: borage, comfrey and phacelia.
- Carrot family: fennel, coriander and parsley, which also support hoverflies and parasitic wasps.
- Fruit trees and brassicas, including a broccoli plant allowed to flower.
The Waikato Beekeepers Association's list leans native. It suggests annuals such as calendula, cornflower, aster, clarkia, coreopsis and gaillardia, and native trees and shrubs by size: lacebark, mānuka and harakeke under five metres, then five finger, kōhūhū and lemonwood, and then cabbage tree, kānuka and weeping kōwhai for larger gardens (Waikato Beekeepers Association).
What wasps want
Wasps aren't after your lavender, at least not primarily. Predator Free NZ explains that hunting wasps roam widely, killing prey and carrying it back to feed their larvae, and that adults then feed on the sugary secretions the larvae produce (Predator Free NZ). In other words, protein goes in one end of the nest and sugar comes out the other.
DOC says the same thing from the management side. The protein-based bait Vespex works only in the warmer months, when wasps are eating protein, and it is not attractive to bees (DOC). Foraging wasps are looking for meat, insects and sweet liquid, not nectar alone, which is why the barbecue and the open jam jar attract them more than the border does.
Habits that keep the balance
None of these require giving up on the bees.
- Keep meat, fish and pet food covered or inside. Protein left outside is a wasp attractant; the DOC explanation of baits rests on exactly that.
- Cover sweet drinks and food. Wasps eat sugar.
- Put compost bins under lids. Open scraps are another protein source.
- Don't leave chicken feed out in the open. The same logic applies.
These are habits rather than rules, and the sources don't quantify any of them, but they follow directly from what wasps are doing.
Be careful with homemade baits
This is the point where the two goals most often collide. University of Auckland researchers advise against homemade poisons, especially those containing sugar, because they attract bees and can contaminate honey (University of Auckland). A jar of sweet liquid set out as a wasp trap might look harmless, but if bees find it first you've done the opposite of what you meant.
If you need to kill a colony, the researchers recommend wasp-specific protein baits and bait stations that keep the poison away from other species, and, for a single nest, dust at the entrance. They name January and February as the best time to act.
Telling them apart at the border
It also helps to be sure what you're watching. Wasps fly faster and more erratically than bees, and pollen on the legs doesn't prove an insect is a bee because wasps also visit flowers and may carry pollen. The Auckland Beekeepers Club says the most helpful clue is the nest: wasps usually nest in the ground or in places like rock walls, while bees are usually higher up, in tree hollows or buildings, where their honeycomb is visible (Auckland Beekeepers Club).
Bumblebees are the large, round, furry ones that bumble between flowers. They're mostly harmless and sting only when seriously provoked.
Bumblebees are worth planting for in their own right. They forage in cooler and wetter weather than honeybees tolerate, and they reach flowers with short tongues that honeybees can't use (Beehive.org.nz). Colonies are small and die out by the end of summer, with the new queens hibernating, so a long run of flowers across the season suits them. The Tasman District Council booklet notes they are attracted to blue, which fits the blue and purple flowers the beekeepers recommend.
If you use an oil spray on the garden, the Auckland Beekeepers Club suggests the late afternoon, when bees are returning to their hives. Timing a spray for the end of the day is a small habit that spares the bees.
A summer rhythm
It might help to think of the year in three stages. In spring, flowers matter most for bees, and queen wasps are looking for nest sites. In summer, keep protein and sugar tidy and watch for traffic to a bank or gap. By late summer, expect wasps to be at their most noticeable, and don't mistake that for failure. A garden full of bees and the occasional wasp is a normal garden.